Elysian Dragonstooth Stout
Oh how tastes differ which is why there are so many variations in style...I gave this stout an A+ or a 90.6 on your scale. Pretty standard flavor profile with what I thought was a world class mouthfeel and extremely fair price.
I agree with Mark with differing tastes, but my biggest issue with the Dragonstooth was the texture and a couple things associate with that in the flavor. Maybe I got a bad bottle, but I was at their pub a couple weeks ago and tried another one of their stouts and it was much thicker (or velvety, haha, but somewhat lighter it wasn't an oatmeal or imperial). They state it is velvety smooth, and if it was I would have liked it much more, because that's what I was hoping for. Did I serve it a little colder than I should, possibly. It's definitely not my favorite PNW stout.
If I experienced the mouth feel you described, I would have probably been very happy, and, the price IS extremely reasonable - no doubt about that! Thanks for the comment! Cheers!